It looks like I have bigger problems.

The plastic cup that the shifter joint sits in is also broken. Does anybody have the part #?

 

http://opposedforces.com/parts/

go there and drill down.

 

I did and the part number isn't listed for it.

What I need is #19 in the diagram.
http://opposedforces.com/parts/fore...ts/forester/us_s11/type_5/manipulation/manual_gear_shift_system/illustration_1/

 

let me look in my collision parts manual, I would have thought it would be in there though, strange they don't have it...

 

Yeah I've been digging for two days. Gonna call the dealer at some point today but the local one is pretty worthless unless I already have the part number....usually.

 

I checked the collision parts manual and they don't have it there either. Honestly your best bet is to call one of the OEM vendors here and have your VIN handy. I'm sure they can help you out. I bet Jackie @ Annapolis Subaru can get you what you need.

 

Any chance the plastic cup is included in an assembly with the bushing and pin? Try 35035AC010.

 

Ian, you are probably right on. The part number they gave me is one digit off.

I went into Capitol Subaru here in Salem and we found the parts in their catalog.

The plastic "cup" (they call it a bushing) is 35035AC020.

Here's a link to my invoice with all the parts for the whole thing:
http://dl.dropbox.com/u/1372454/foresterpics/Photo Dec 20, 1 55 22 PM.jpg

As it turns out Subaru is shutting down their parts warehouse for the next week and they said that I wouldn't get the parts until the 2nd unless I had them overnighted.

Pro-tip: Don't break your Subaru at the end of the year.