Subaru Forester Owners Forum banner
  • The "Garage" feature is for images of YOUR VEHICLE/S only - no blanks or other unrelated images please, thanks

2015 - Failed safety inspection at dealer due to front low control arm bushing - questions?

4.8K views 18 replies 10 participants last post by  Black21Limited  
#1 · (Edited)
Vehicle Details:
2015 forester
Transmission:
CVT
Greetings!

I took my car to Subaru dealership last weekend for annual safety inspection. it didn't pass because of a broken brake light and front lower control arm bushing needs to be replaced. Dealer quoted me $55 for brake light replacement, $1235 for lower control arm bushings replacement, and $165 for alignment. I declined and they put a rejection sticker on my windshield and gave me 2 weeks to fix it.

here's my questions:
1. I can replace brake light myself, but replacing front control arm bushings is out of my league, what's a fair price to pay for the replacement?
2. If i replaced bushing at my local auto shop, do i have to bring car back to dealership for re-inspection? I'm concerned that they will fail my car again if it didn't meet dealer's 'safety standard'

Location is Washington DC - northern Virginia area
 
#2 · (Edited)
You could have an entire new LCA installed, that comes with new bushings, and possibly a new ball joint.

Replacing the entire assembly might even be something you could accomplish, if you have basic mechanical skills, and the tools.

The axle stub nut might be the toughest part getting it broken loose, and torqued back to spec.

Having the shop replace the assembly if you provide it, might also be cheaper than having the bushing replaced. Less labor.

You could then save the old one, and have the improved bushings installed later, and have one ready to go for the next time.
 
#5 ·
You could have an entire new LCA installed, that comes with new bushings, and possibly a new ball joint.

Replacing the entire assembly might even be something you could accomplish, if you have basic mechanical skills, and the tools.

The axle stub nut might be the toughest part getting it broken loose, and torqued back to spec.

Having the shop replace the assembly if you provide it, might also be cheaper than having the bushing replaced. Less labor.

You could then save the old one, and have the improved bushings installed later, and have one ready to go for the next time.

thanks!

I found front control arms that fit my vehicle on amazon, not OEM but seems receiving good reviews, I am thinking buying these and have local shop replaces them for me.

Left LCA https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B073ZBVNYY/ref=ox_sc_act_title_1?smid=ATVPDKIKX0DER&psc=1
Right LCA https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B073ZCD89N/ref=ox_sc_act_title_2?smid=ATVPDKIKX0DER&psc=1
 
#8 ·
I paid around $1200 for front lower control arm bushings, alignment, front brake pads (no rotors) and some light engine tuneup stuff.

This was about 2.5 years ago at an independent shop which specializes in Subaru's here in Atlanta. The dealership will necessarily be higher.

Here in Georgia, inspection results go to the state electronically and all other inspection stations have access to the data. All inspection stations will therefor know why it failed. Not sure if VA is the same but would be surprised if VA wasn't more sophisticated than GA. Most third world countries are more sophisticated than GA.
 
#9 ·
Do you need to pull the hub to do LCAs on newer Foresters? I just did mine and everything is accessible with the wheels on. Still should get an alignment, and do both sides at the same time, but definitely better to replace the whole LCA than try to press in/out new bushings.
 
#13 ·
SC did away with vehicle inspections years ago, mostly due to a state imposed limit on what an inspector could charge. It simply wasn’t worth any shop’s time and effort to actually inspect a vehicle, so just about every shop that stayed in the inspection business just slapped the sticker on the vehicle without even looking at the tires and collected the meager fee.

It was a well-known way of doing the inspection business, and instead of the legislature actually addressing the problems with the program, they instead simply repealed the law requiring state inspections. That happened decades ago.

There are some really unsafe vehicles on the road in SC, and one doesn’t have to look very hard to find some of them…
 
Save
#15 ·
thanks guys!

just to report back -

I took my car to a local auto repair shop and have them examined the car: they replaced both front LCAs, non-functioning brake light, they also recommend the front l/f side wheel bearing and hub assembly replacement since it's running low, which I did, together with four wheel alignment, and state safety inspection cost me $1399.30.

The car handles much better now since it makes much less noise on the road, shop mentioned the noise was caused by the over-worn front wheel bearing. this actually made me to look at my car maintenance record: a year ago (Jan '23) I took the car to Subaru dealer for the excessive noise while driving and dealer replaced the rear wheel hub assembly, afterwards the noise level didn't change much, and I thought this is a common problem for Subaru, now I'm glad that local shop fix it for me.
 
#17 ·
A lower control arm with a lifetime warranty is $140 at autozone, anytime it fails after that you get a free part.
Installation is extra, but I do my own repairs.

Fairly easy to remove.
Image

Since a new LCA usually includes a new ball joint, unbolt the other end of the ball joint.

An easy project if someone is looking to start doing some of their own repairs.
 
You have insufficient privileges to reply here.