Subaru Forester Owners Forum banner
  • The "Garage" feature is for images of YOUR VEHICLE/S only - no blanks or other unrelated images please, thanks

2010 - XT AT - Is it safe to drive from Sapporo to Niseko with a faulty radiator fan?

133 views 4 replies 4 participants last post by  DragonSubie7  
#1 ·
Vehicle Details:
XT 2.0 2010 model
Transmission:
Auto
Location:
Sapporo Japan
Hello all,

I'm hoping to get some advice from the community on a tricky situation I'm in with my 2010 Forester XT. My car has been parked in a long-term car park in Sapporo, and I just received an email from the parking company (Sun Parking) with some bad news.

Their mechanic took a look and found that the radiator fan is not working. The issue appears to be electrical—he noted that "the current is not reaching the radiator fan" and "the voltage for the fan relay is also not what it should be." He suspects a problem with the car's computer (ECU) and was unable to test it further, saying that only a Subaru dealership can handle the electronics.

The car cannot be driven at the moment, and I've been unable to get in touch with a Subaru dealership to arrange a tow.
My question is this: Would it be safe to drive the car from Sapporo to Niseko? The journey is about 100km. My reasoning is twofold:
  1. I have a trusted mechanic in Niseko who I'd prefer to take it to.
  2. Given the cold temperatures in Hokkaido, would the natural airflow from driving be enough to keep the engine from overheating?
I know a tow is the safest option, but I'm looking to see if this is a viable alternative to get it back to my preferred mechanic. Is this a terrible idea, or is there a way to do it without risking engine damage?

Any advice or experience you could share would be a huge help.
Thanks in advance.
 
Engine: EJ20 CBA-SH5 SH5-026564
#3 ·
Basically, it will likely be OK as long as the car keeps moving. But if you do sustained high speed, like on the motorway, then hit traffic and come to a stop, the car will probably overheat. Ask me how I know.

Follow Kevin's advice, or get the local mechanic to rig up a switch and some wire that powers at least one fan directly that you can turn on from inside the car should you need it.

In the absence of the above, I'd do the trip late at night when the air is cold and the roads are clear, keep to a gentle cruise in top gear at under 2500 rpm so that it stays off boost and cover the last few miles with the revs as low as possible so the engine is as cool as possible when you stop. And in the last several miles, crank the heater to full and the blowers to max with the windows down to dump as much heat as you can before stopping.

But it's a risk. A tow is much cheaper than a new engine.
 
#5 ·
Given the cold temperatures in Hokkaido, would the natural airflow from driving be enough to keep the engine from overheating?
If it's cold (relative I know) and you are driving at highway speed, it doubtful that your fans would ever be running.
Driving at highway speed will put more air through the radiator than the fans will.
Speeds above 30 mph /48 kph will typically turn the radiator fans off.
Stops and slow driving, especially in warm temperatures are when the fans normally kick in.

As noted, you could hook up a jumper to the fan(s) to keep them running if you are concerned that you'll hit some heavy traffic. I'd add a jumper with a quick connector under the hood that can be plugged in in the event the engine warms up too much. It can be easily removed once you have the car repaired.
 
You have insufficient privileges to reply here.