Okay, I know jack about minis aside from the standard specs. I was trying to convince her to go with the John Works edition but she wants to have an S for as cheap as possible. Anything to lookout for? I think the 2010s come with an automatic but I was trying to get her a MT...and I am thinking the '09s that are leftover will be the best bet for pricing now. I was trying to convince her to get a Legacy GT or a new WRX 4door but not sure she likes those too much...still have to go test drive the three cars. Any help would be great. Thanks!