I have tricked out an 09 Forester. Intake, STI exhaust, front/rear brace bars and sound system. I can honestly say that the 2019 Forester Sport is the first Forester I have been excited about in 10 years.
Orange is my favorite color, so I get why many don't like it. I love this car. I went with package 24. The 8" monitor is a huge improvement and the first time it has been offered in the Forester. I also have the HK upgrade and I am impressed!!! The bass output in the front of the car is quite amazing. The doors are running 6x9 speakers, which are massive for doors. Most people will think this sounds system is plenty. While it has a clean sounding 8" sub in the back, it was underpowered for me. I am having a subwoofer upgrade made for the other side of the rear cargo area. I've only had the car two weeks, so sill be starting a build page in a few weeks, like I did back in teh day for my 09.
Kericks, here are a few responses to your questions.
AWD Subarus, truly are snow machines. Almost all models excel in winter. The Forester is no exception. I live in Flagstaff, AZ and frequent the ski mountain regularly. I have always been able to zip up and down that mountain with great traction will often see 4x4 trucks sliding out on the turns. This is very unlikely in the Forester because it is lighter and lower to the ground. My Dodge Ram is great in mud, sand and for hauling, but when it comes to snow and ice, the Subaru will be your best bet.
Gas mileage is avg 29mpg. A step up from 23 in my 09.
Here are some things you should know about the features:
1. X mode on the Sport has two modes. you can really feel the difference. The engine will run higher rpm in deep snow mode and feels very grippy. The center display will show you the traction being delivered to each wheel as they engage. All this is automatic and sensed by the car. What you must know is that X mode only works under 20 mph. This is a feature designed for rough terrain in slow speeds. It will not work at higher speeds.
2. The Hill decent mode is quite impressive too. Basically on steep down hil terrain, you can take your foot off the pedals and the car will choose the correct speed and braking for your decent. It goes slow, again for rough terrain. All you have to do is steer.
3. LED fog lights really widen the light range in front of the car and outwards about 6 feet further on each side. These work way better than traditional yellow fog lights I had on the 09. I suppose the steering responsive lights would be better, but not available in the Sport trim.
4. IMO, the upgrades are worth it for snow country. You get two x modes and paddle shifters. I love the paddles. Just remember, that if you are in Auto then the paddle will shift down/up but then return to auto in about 20 seconds. So, if you are in rough/icy terrain, just put the gear into manual and use the paddle shifters to control your gear. Manual mode is truly the way to go when driving in icy conditions. I use the motor to slow the car and not the brakes, thereby maintaining traction and power and avoiding locking the wheels on an icy patch where you will likely slide.
Even my wife prefers to drive the Subaru over the truck in the winter. Full size trucks are too tall and too heavy to be snow machines. They are much better in off-road dry/wet conditions, not snow/ice.
BTW, I do run dedicated non-studded snow tires in the winter on dedicated rims. I just swap the wheels for summer/winter driving. You can likely get a good deal on the entry level Sport for around $28K. I think it is worth it.
I hope this helps. Good luck with your decision.
Cheers,
Scott