They were frosted over in this pic. I do still have the headlights all stock. Planning on using the baking method and blacking them out. I'll try plasti dip and I believe that I might also do my rims while I'm at it. Thanks for the advice
Powder coating would look much better in my opinion and would last longer than PlastiDip, but it's permanent, harder to touch up (if something does chip) and will be more expensive.
I like PlastiDip as a starting point. It's super cheap, gives you a good idea of what things will look like and it's removable. You can always go back to the way it was, or remove it and paint or powder coat.
Powder coating is tricky on plastics and I believe some shops won't do it, so it might be a little more difficult to powder coat your grille.