Subaru Forester Owners Forum banner
1 - 3 of 25 Posts

· Registered
2019 Forester Touring
Joined
·
2,378 Posts
Here’s another opinion, for what it’s worth...

While it appears the dealership is attempting to be “stand-up” and dping the right thing, in the end you’re still getting a 10 year old vehicle, and very few 10 year old vehicles stay trouble-free for any extended lengths of time. ALL moving parts, as well as electronics, has lifespans... and some of these components can be quite expensive to repair/replace. Even with a completely new engine, you’ll still be driving on a transmission and suspension with 130K miles on the clock.

Not an attempt to dissuade you from keeping the vehicle and getting it repaired, but just a reminder that even if the dealership does a class ‘A‘ job going over the vehicle, there are likely things that won’t be addressed (ie., worn brake pads/rotors that will need replacing in a few thousand miles, as a lower costing example... drive train components can be, and usually are, far more expensive).

Personally, I think this has the potential to be a great vehicle for one that has the willingness and technical capability to do much of the repair work on their own, but I’d be hesitant to recommend it to repair-shop-dependent purchaser.

If you do select to retain the vehicle, then I’d suggest you create a repair “reserve fund” to deal with any unexpected breakdowns/failures. If you never need it, then it’s just more money in your pocket.
 

· Registered
2019 Forester Touring
Joined
·
2,378 Posts
Well, believe it or not XT's are in huge demand. Chances are they got it in as a trade-in, and with in a week it was sold.
That's pretty much my story on my '14 XT. It was the right price for my budget and it was only on the dealer lot for less than 2 weeks before I bought it.

But as to not de-rail the original topic, If it was me I'll let the dealer put a new engine in it. If it is not going to cost me anything and they will pay for it, why not? Dealer warranty on a 10 year old car, not a bad deal if you ask me.
Now...if I had to pay for even half if it, I would just sell the car back to them.
Well, that 1 year warranty is for the engine alone. As has been pointed out, that’s hardly the only item to cause serious expense(s) on a 10 year old vehicle.

@SubaruSpouse gave an excellent analysis of how to approach the issue. If the deal is “buy now or never”, sometimes it pays to select the “never” option. Always go into a multi-$1000 deal with a clear mind, or you’re likely gonna get a huge (and probably expensive) disappointment at some point
 

· Registered
2019 Forester Touring
Joined
·
2,378 Posts
Just remember the disclaimer every financial investment offer includes...

”Past performance does not guarantee future results”. There seems to be a lot of unknowns here, so I’d advise proceeding with great caution...

Good Luck in whatever you decide.
 
1 - 3 of 25 Posts
Top